too expensive

My dog likes this treat but they are very small bites. Probably good for cats or small dogs.

My very picky dog likes these!

small dogs loved it

Dog likes them a lot, and the cat likes them too if you break them into smaller pieces.

The dogs love them a tub is pictured but they came in a bag some what of a deal for me

This item arrived in different packaging but was otherwise as described - would recommend

Yum.

Best dog treat on the market.My dog can't and won't eat anything with flour in it. Mathis is pure, meat. Yet neat and clean.

My dog loves these liver treats, but the expiration date on the bottom was four months from when I bought them, so I give these only four starts.

OUR DOG LOVE IT!!!!

Easy to break into little pieces so can be used for stuffing into toys or giving as treats. My dogs love them.

You dog will love you.

Stay fresh a long time because they're freeze dried. My dogs will do absolutely anything for these treats!

All the dogs I used these training treats on, love them.

The bits were bigger than I expected.

pups loved it!

Good liver treats. Highly recommend.

My picky babes love these I will buy them again.

My 3 doggies VERY favorite treat!

What's not to love - the dogs will do anything for freeze dried liver snacks!!!

ALL five of my dogs LOVE these!! I have shih tzus that sometimes have sensitive tummys so I am very careful what kind of treats my dogs get....but these are AWESOME, have never had them get an upset belly from them....and they all love them tsooooo much!

My doggie loves it. Recommended by a fellow dog walker.

Our dog absolutely loves these Liver Bits!!! they are small, and easy to give as either a "training treat" or a "regular treat" without overdoing how much you are giving your dog. Great treats!

These are like crack to my dog. He'll do any trick he can think of as soon as he knows I have some in my hand. However, the pieces are much too big to be used as training treats. I cut them into smaller pieces, but they are pretty brittle, so I ended up with both pieces and unusable crumbs/dust. Also, note that 4oz doesn't sound like much, but keep in mind that all moisture is removed from these, so each treat weighs almost nothing. The container shown is about 2/3 full and is about the size of a roll of toilet paper for size reference.

Too Hard

My picky dog loves them

Dog loves these little treats. Easy to give, not messy, and perfect size that they can be given multiple times a day without adding too many calories. The bites are about the size of an ounce of cheese.

Great training aid. Pup loves them and they can easily be broken into smaller pieces.

What is not to love about pure, dried liver? Even the cats go nuts of this stuff. I will always keep some on hand.

My dogs just loves them, couldn't get enough, I have to restrict them to one per day as I have six in my pack. Will definitely buy more when I am out again. Highly recommended to any dog lovers.

This is the only way I can get her to go in her crate at night. She will do anything for a piece of this treat!

My boys loved these ad I didn't feel guilty about giving them to them. There's nothing but natural lire in these. Just dehydrated. How can I go wrong.

My shi tzu absolutely loves these and he seems to not get enough. These are his favorite!!! I wish they came in larger sizes.

Got these for free with another order and my doggie LOVES them. When I shake the container he comes running! They are somewhat stinky, almost a stale smell, but most dog treats have some sort of odor. I love that these are real liver, just a simple all natural treat.

My little girl loves them so it fits the bill! Plus I got them free with another purchase so I was happy. P.s. My dog is a picky eater and sometimes turns down treats people give her if they are not up to her "standards".

... and I felt it was healthier for him than some of the waxy treats you can buy at the grocery store.

They are easy to break up into even smaller pieces and I can put them in her treat balls that she loves to play with.

Received these treats in a sort of "package" deal with another purchase. I wasn't sure how my dog would respond, but she absolutely loved the treats -- enough so that she knew where to run to when asked if she wanted a "liver treat".

I got a sample of these freeze dried liver bits with an order through another website. I liked them so much, I ordered more (they were cheaper on Amazon). Most treats dry out after a day, but these are already dried so I can leave them out and they don't get gross. And the dog loves them!!

purchased 2 of these. both came expired. Product expiration date was 11/23/12. they were ordered 12/9/12. I do not give expired dog treats/food to the dogs... too many health risks

My dog and my sons dog goes crazy for these treats. I do not particularly like the smell, but since I am not eating them it really does not matter.

Can't say I purchased this for our dogs because it came as a freebe with a purchase here on Amazon. I brought it to the local animal shelter and have to say that they were very appreciative since they used it for training and the dogs excitedly expressed their approval of the product. Can't ask for a more glowing review.

My dogs loved these. Of course, they would eat dirt if you put marinara sauce on it. I like the fact that these are organic, healthy treats.

I have 3 Italian Greyhounds who love these!! even my picky eater. They high in calorie so I limit them to 1 daily but it gives them a high dose of protein!

These treats worked miracles with our dog. We have an old basset who needs Ringers Lactate solution through an intravenous drip. She was reluctant to get her treatment (twice a week) until we bought these treats. Now she heads to the pillow where she receives the fluid because she knows she's getting the liver bits!bob w

My dogs loved them. Healthy and good nutrients. Makes training a lot easier, good tool.Good price, recommend to any pet lover.

My dog (a 6# male Chihuahua) absoluely loves theses treats.He is limited to two per day but would eat the whole container if I let him. Ergo, I will be purhasing in the future.

My dog's new favorite treat... The pieces are very inconsistent, but a dog doesn't seem to care... Only thing is I don't see how these could be a training treat, some of the pieces are as big as my pinky finger... But anyways, it is obviously a very high quality treat and I was pleasantly surprised when I got them. Oh, and don't be fooled by the ounces (quantity)... these treats are dried, so you get a lot.

Obviously this is second-hand as I certainly have not tried them. The label states and by appearance this is freeze-dried liver that's cut into treat sized chunks. Our dog loves them and has never said no. They came with a pretty substantial time frame left on the expiration.