I got these as a gift for a friend's dalmation (Yuki) but before I could deliver them my cats got into the container and helped themselves! When the remainder finally made it to my friend and her dog, her dog loved them so much my friend has to ration them -- I think if Yuki had her way she'd eat the whole 4 ounces in a minute! Also, this company is great -- got my order quickly and in great condition.

First - these are some very nice, high-quality freeze-dried liver treats. Both of our dogs love them.They're great training treats for several reasons:1) Freeze-dried so they're not messy2) Dogs think they're incredibly yummy (I haven't tried them myself...)3) Because they're yummy, they're motivational4) They come in nice small-sized chunksThey're not perfect treats for other purposes. For example, you can't use these to hide a pill inside to get medication into your furry friend - you need soft treats to do that. If your dog is extremely scent-motivated, I'm not sure how well these would work since I don't detect any strong scent or odor from them - but the dogs love the taste!We got these for free with a medication order, and we really like them. I'd definitely have paid the asking price, so if you're considering this purchase, go ahead. I don't think you'll be disappointed!

And they aren't made in China, so I have a high degree of comfort, they are a high quality treat.

You will know if your pet likes these within a heartbeat. I now buy the 19.5oz to get more for my money. These are great for overweight dogs but keep it at a maximum of 5 or so a day. These are high in protein and are as natural as they can get.Very easy storage and have not had an issue with freshness. I like to keep a 4oz tub on hand to refill from my 19.5oz. You will not be disappointed!

The value of these treats is quite good & they smell exactly like chopped liver or pate. The pieces are on the larger side, so I break them up into smaller bits for my 5-lb puppy, but they still take awhile for her to chew them up so they're not good for training like I'd hoped. If she was a bigger dog, I suspect I'd be giving the full 5 stars

These treats are very dry and brittle. We like smaller, moist treats for training rather than the dryness and varying sizes of the blocks that come in this container. Our pup would always eat these treats, but he wasn't as eager in training as he can be with others.

My dog loves these Liver Bits! I wish I had found them sooner. Great for training, no preservatives and full of protein. My little Sparky just loves them. I am going to buy a few containers and give them as presents for family members pups. I think these are great!

My pup is hooked on these Liver Bits! These have got to be the best training treats ever created because my dog will do virtually anything I tell him to do just to get one! On top of that, it's 100% all natural beef liver, zero preservatives and only 13 calories per bit! Finally, a treat that I can give Tyson without the worries of fattening him up!